In the contemporary geopolitical environment, power is not reflected solely in a state’s capacity to act. It is also reflected in its ability to consistently explain what it is doing, why it is doing it, and within which institutional and legal framework.
The implementation and execution of any strategy encompass a less visible—yet equally significant—dimension: that of “meaning-making.” This concerns, specifically, how events are interpreted, framed, and presented to the international community, with the aim of shaping perceptions and exerting influence.
Meaning-making
Meaning-making is a dynamic communicative process through which events are not merely transmitted as raw information; rather, they are interpreted, imbued with significance, and integrated into broader frameworks for understanding reality.
Communication, therefore, is not limited to the transmission of messages; it contributes to the formation—and co-formation—of interpretive frameworks, particularly in environments characterized by uncertainty, tension, and competing interests.
In the realm of international relations, this process acquires particular geopolitical significance, as states seek not only to project their own version of events unfolding in the international arena but also to influence how third-party states, international organizations, and the international community as a whole perceive and evaluate them.
The selection of elements to be highlighted, the manner in which they are interpreted, and the context in which they are presented can shape the perceptions and judgments of international audiences, thereby imbuing communication with a broader strategic dimension.
In this way, the construction of meaning is directly linked to the shaping of perceptions, the exercise of influence, and the pursuit of international legitimacy.
The concept of narrative dominance
In this context, the concept of “narrative dominance” emerges, referring to the ability of a state—or another actor—to project its own interpretation of events and render it more persuasive and influential than competing versions.
This goes beyond the mere rapid dissemination of information or the promotion of a political stance; it entails the construction of a coherent and compelling narrative designed to shape how international audiences perceive and evaluate a given situation.
In the contemporary geopolitical environment, confrontation is not limited to the mere presentation of differing positions; rather, it extends to shaping the perceptions of third-party states, international organizations, and the international community as a whole.
In this context, the speed of a communicative response is of particular importance, as the initial interpretation of an event can establish the primary framework through which subsequent developments are evaluated.
However, narrative superiority is not secured solely by the timely articulation of a claim or a policy stance.
It requires consistency, credibility, substantiation, and alignment between a state’s public-facing communication and its actual political, diplomatic, and operational conduct.
The objective is to foster greater acceptance of one’s own version of events and, by extension, to exert influence over the perceptions and assessments of third-party actors.
In contemporary geopolitics, states compete not only for control over territories, maritime areas, energy resources, and strategic infrastructure.
They also compete over how the international community perceives events, assigns responsibility, and evaluates the conduct of the actors involved.
Shaping these perceptions can influence the international legitimacy of an actor and its positions, the stance of third-party states and international organizations, and, ultimately, the political and diplomatic environment in which decisions are made.
The individual stages of the process
In this light, the scenario of competition between two states can be analyzed through a sequence of seven distinct yet interconnected stages, which captures the transition from the event itself to its interpretation and, ultimately, to the pursuit of influence—tracing the path from event to meaning, and from meaning to influence.
Mapping this process requires examining the individual stages through which an actual occurrence is transformed into a subject of interpretation, narrative competition, and the exercise of influence. Specifically, these stages are as follows:
1.The Event
The starting point of the process is the actual sequence of events. The first state issues directives—for example, regarding entry into the country’s Flight Information Region (FIR), NAVTEX notices, or a note verbale—in order to complete the established authorization procedures.
The other-second state responds with a counter-directive—mirroring the type issued by the first state—reiterating its own positions regarding jurisdiction over parts of the area in question. Concurrently, a third state provides a diplomatic communication to the second state concerning the use of a directive that it (the third state) had issued exclusively to the first state.
These events constitute the factual backdrop of the confrontation, even before they are subjected to the varying interpretations and narratives of the actors involved.
2. Interpretation
The same diplomatic event takes on a different meaning depending on the perspective and objectives of each involved party. From the standpoint of the third state, the communication with the second state constitutes a diplomatic briefing; it does not imply the adoption of a position regarding legal disputes, nor does it prejudge the status of the aerial or maritime areas in question.
Conversely, the second state seeks to attribute a different significance to this same communication, presenting it as an acknowledgment of the importance of its own position and role in managing developments within the area under consideration.
Thus, a single event—namely, the diplomatic briefing provided by the third state to the second state—gives rise to two distinct interpretations, which reflect the differing political and geopolitical objectives of the actors involved.
3. Framing
The communicative confrontation shifts from the actual nature of the diplomatic notification provided by a third state to the question of whether the second state was notified—and, crucially, whether this communication can be construed as a recognition of its role or an acceptance of its claims regarding the area in question.
In this context, the selection of elements to be highlighted—and the emphasis placed upon them—becomes particularly significant, as does the downplaying of other elements that might otherwise lead to a different interpretation.
In this way, the event itself is situated within a specific interpretive framework, which influences how it is perceived and evaluated by the international community.
4. Narrative
At this stage, the isolated incident is integrated into a broader strategic narrative, linked to the long-standing geopolitical objectives of each party. The second state seeks to frame this development within a wider narrative, according to which any activity in the area in question—over which it asserts claims—must take its positions and demands into account.
In this way, it seeks to present its presence and claims as a factor that must be taken into account in any relevant activity within the region. The first state, for its part, maintains that the prescribed licensing procedures have been completed by its competent authorities and that the implementation of the project does not require the consent of the second state.
The two approaches, therefore, reflect competing strategic narratives, through which the actors involved attempt to frame the specific event within their own understanding of the status, rules, and balance of power in the region in question.
5. Perception
At this stage, the focus shifts to how third-party states, European institutions, international organizations, business entities, and the media perceive and evaluate the development.
The effectiveness of a strategic narrative depends, to a significant extent, on the degree to which it is understood, gains credibility, and influences the perceptions of international audiences.
However, while the systematic repetition and projection of a claim may strengthen its presence in public and diplomatic discourse, this does not automatically imply its acceptance, nor does it confer upon it any legal validity. Therefore, the critical stake for every actor involved is to make their own interpretation more persuasive and credible in the eyes of the international community.
6. Legitimacy
At this stage, each side seeks to present its own position as institutionally and politically justified, thereby strengthening international acceptance of its arguments while undermining the credibility of the opposing side’s claims.
This endeavor is linked to the shaping of international political legitimacy, which influences how third-party states and international organizations evaluate the conduct of the actors involved.
However, the public presentation of a position is no substitute for its legal substantiation. Legal legitimacy does not derive from the articulation or repetition of a narrative; rather, it is assessed based on the applicable rules of international law and the specific facts of each case.
Consequently, the pursuit of international legitimacy through communication and the legal grounding of a position constitute two distinct, albeit interrelated, dimensions.
7. Influence
The ultimate objective of this process is to exert influence over the perceptions, attitudes, and judgments of international audiences—in a manner that may shape diplomatic stances, policy decisions, and the international response to the project in the region under consideration.
Specifically, each side seeks to shape a more favorable political and diplomatic environment for its positions and objectives by influencing how third states, international organizations, and other relevant actors assess developments.
Influence, therefore, is not an automatic consequence of communication activities, but rather the intended outcome of a broader strategic process—the effectiveness of which depends on the credibility, consistency, and acceptance of the narrative being projected.
Conclusion
The above sequence reveals that the confrontation surrounding a project in an area under consideration does not take place solely in the diplomatic or operational sphere, but also in the realm of communication—specifically, in the construction of meaning.
The first state in this case, must proactively establish the framework within which any development is perceived, and take initiatives to strengthen its position as a leading and credible actor in shaping the international landscape for the dissemination of information and the interpretation of events.
In this context, a coherent communication strategy is required, with a clear distinction between the provision of information, consultation, consensus-building, and approval.
Furthermore, systematic and timely briefing of international institutions and allies/partners is essential, as is a well-substantiated presentation of the facts and a consistent emphasis on the character of the project in the under consideration area.
*AI was used for the photograph




